Recipes Shop Local

10 Ways to Make Peanut Butter Coffee

This month’s coffee club flavor was none other than Peanut Butter! Our community has been raving about the newest Coffee Club flavor and sharing lots of ways to enjoy it. The possibilities are truly endless, so we wanted to share some suggestions from them on how to enjoy our newest addition!

Did you know you can mix our coffees? LOTS of moms like to put 1/2 one flavor and 1/2 another into their brew basket or cold brew maker. Here are some suggestions straight from our community for Surviving Motherhood Coffee flavors to mix with Peanut Butter:

Creamers and other mix-ins to spice it up:

  • Milk: for those who love simplicity.
  • Chocolate milk: for a peanut butter cup treat!
  • Chocolate and caramel sauce: Shanon had this great idea and says, “it tastes like a snickers!”.
  • Drizzle Hersey chocolate syrup on the rim, and add Italian sweet cream: hello delicious! Shakeela shared this idea and says, “the peanut butter flavor is so subtle and smooth, not overpowering at all!”
  • Starbucks Caramel Macchiato creamer or Caramel Creamer: we love your creamer suggestions, because they give us so many options!
  • Skinny Mocha Syrup: another addition to take it from peanut butter dream to chocolate peanut butter heaven!
  • M&M Creamer with a splash of salted caramel syrup: Lindsey has us dreaming of dessert with this one!
  • Chobani Sweet Cream and a touch of mocha creamer: Thanks to Aimee for this idea. She said, “I make it iced, it’s delish – like a candy bar!”
Fueled by Caffeine and Chaos Mug

What is everyone saying about this month’s flavor?

  • “Sooooo good!” – Jacki
  • “It’s the perfect amount of flavor without being too much flavor! It’s my favorite to date.” – Lindsay
  • “Omg best flavor so far!!! I love it!!!! I put a little vanilla oat milk in it and OMG!!!” – Jodee
  • “This was amazing!” – Kelly
  • “Amazeballs 🤷🏼‍♀️🤣 lol. I was really hesitant at first but made a pot and it’s definitely not what you’re thinking of when you think of that flavor! I had some black and with oat milk and it was delish!” – Kayla
  • “It’s smooth with just a hint of flavor…. delish!” – Lindsey

Some of you have expressed your FOMO on missing out the Coffee Club flavors. Don’t miss the next opportunity to signup and join the club. You can signup for the next delicious mystery flavor on July 19th by clicking here!

While you wait for signups shop all Surviving Motherhood Coffee and Tea here!

More FAQs? Shoot Gina a text or join the community! You can text her at 774-425-7282 and click here to join our community on Facebook!

You Might Also Like

No Comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.